5 Best and Worst States for Paying Off Student Loan Debt

study-best-worst-states-cities-for-paying-off-student-loans

If it often feels like you can’t ever make more than a small dent in your student loan debt, you’re certainly not alone. And according to our latest study, it’s not just a feeling – it’s a fact.

We took a look at the average student loan balance for 2015 graduates in each state and compared it to the state’s living costs and wages. The goal: to see how affordable student loan payments are (or aren’t) for new grads across the country.


The key indicator Student Loan Hero examined to determine student loan affordability was the percentage of a typical graduate’s monthly disposable income that would go towards student loan payments (assuming the standard 10-year repayment period).

To be considered affordable, the average student loan payment should equate to 10 percent or less of a graduate’s disposable income – similar to how the federal government caps payments under most income-driven repayment plans.

However, none of the states or the District of Columbia passed this standard. The state with the most affordable student debt came close at 10.9 percent of disposable income.

On the other end of the spectrum, graduates in the state with the least affordable student loans could expect to put about 30 percent of disposable income toward their debt.

Finally, on the national level, student loan payments are equal to 17.3 percent of disposable income, on average.

Here’s a look at the five states where graduates have the most room in their budgets to repay loans and the five states where graduates are most burdened by their student debt.

5 best states for paying back student debt

In the five states that top our rankings, residents have more room in their budgets to repay student loans than the rest of the country. Among the states where student loan repayment is most affordable, a common trend is lower levels of debt upon graduating.

Utah, the top-ranking state in this study, had an average student loan balance of $18,873 among 2015 graduates. That’s more than $11,000 less than the 2015 national average of $30,100.

But that doesn’t tell the whole story. Low cost of living was an important factor in making student loan payments more affordable for many of these states. And for states in which cost of living and student loan debt crept higher, such as Colorado and Washington, the best states matched those with higher wages.

Here’s an overview of the five states that topped our rankings for student loan affordability.

5. Colorado

  • Average student loan balance: $25,840
  • Average annual wage: $51,180
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 13.86%

For Colorado residents, the state’s higher wages give them the biggest boost in keeping up with student loans. Plus, cost of living in this state is slightly cheaper than the national average.

An average Colorado resident earns an additional $2,860 per year over the national average of $48,320, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That’s an extra $240 a month, which is close to the $262 monthly payment on the average student loan balance.

4. Washington

  • Average student loan balance: $24,600
  • Average annual wage: $54,010
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 13.33%

Washington edged out Colorado for the No. 4 spot with both higher incomes and lower levels of student debt.

Wages in Washington are $5,000 higher than the median, while residents pay living costs on par with the rest of the country.

This combined with lower balances means that a typical Washington graduate can easily cover a $249 monthly payment still have $1,620 in disposable income left over each month.

3. Wyoming

  • Average student loan balance: $22,683
  • Average annual wage: $45,850
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 13.31%

Wyoming very barely edged out Washington, mostly due to lower starting student loan balances. Graduates of Wyoming schools are likely able to keep borrowing low thanks in large part to the state’s low tuition rates. Annual in-state tuition and fees at public Wyoming colleges are the lowest in the nation at just over $5,000, according to data from The College Board.

Residents of Wyoming are also helped by below-average living costs and earning wages higher than residents of most other states.

2. New Mexico

  • Average student loan balance: $20,193
  • Average annual wage: $43,170
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 12.22%

New Mexico landed in the No. 2 spot due to its low levels of student loan borrowing and affordable living costs.

With typical student debt at $20,193, the average New Mexico graduate owes about $10,000 less than the national average. Even with annual wages that are $5,000 below the national average, New Mexico graduates’ low debts are still affordable.

1. Utah (best)

  • Average student loan balance: $18,873
  • Average annual wage: $44,130
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 10.89%

Of all the states, Utah’s ratio of student debt to income is closest to the affordable level of 10 percent. This reflects the state’s affordable in-state tuition, currently the fourth-lowest in the nation at $6,581 per year at a four-year institution.

But it’s also indicative of a student culture that’s resistant to borrowing for college. Both the amounts borrowed by Utah graduates, just under $19,000 on average and the portion of graduates with student debts, 41 percent, are the lowest in the nation.

“I think that Utahns reflect the conservative nature of trying to avoid debt and trying to be very responsible about the debt that is taken on,” said David Buhler, commissioner of higher education, in an interview with Utah news network KSL.

5 worst states for paying back student loans

In the states where student loans are the least affordable, high costs of living make it difficult for graduates to keep up with their higher student loan balances.

Among these states, the ratio of student debt to disposable income was as high as 30 percent. This is despite the fact that residents of these states earn wages that are in the top half of states.

Residents these states devote so much of their income to basic living expenses that they end up with little disposable income. Hawaii and New York, for instance, landed among the top 5 due to having some of the highest costs of living in the nation.

But the five worst-ranked states include those with the highest levels of student loan debt. In New Hampshire, for instance, the average student loan balance for a graduate is a staggering $36,101 (nearly twice as much as best-ranked state Utah).

Here’s a rundown of the five states where graduates’ budgets are stretched the thinnest and student loans are the least affordable.

5. Rhode Island

  • Average student loan balance: $32,920
  • Average annual wage: $50,780
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 22.64%

Rhode Island graduates have the fifth-highest student loan debt in any state, which results in average monthly payments of $333. The state also has a cost of living that’s 15.6 percent higher than the national average.

The combined higher student loan balances and living costs means Rhode Island residents will have a hard time keeping up with student loan payments. This is true even though the state’s typical wages that beat the national average by $2,460 annually (an extra $205 a month).

4. Connecticut

  • Average student loan balance: $34,773
  • Average annual wage: $56,280
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 24.52%

High student debt (the third-highest in the nation) put Connecticut among the five worst states for student loan affordability. Monthly student loan payments tip the scales at $352, which is a quarter of the typical Connecticut resident’s $1,436 monthly disposable income.

The high student debt is offset somewhat by higher wages, which amount to an extra $663 a month above the average. But it’s not enough to match the state’s costly expenses. Connecticut’s average wages are 16 percent higher than the national average, while its living costs are 23 percent higher.

3. New Hampshire

  • Average student loan balance: $36,101
  • Average annual wage: $48,710
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 25.35%

Graduates in this state have to stretch those average wages a lot further to cover the state’s high student debts. New Hampshire has the highest rate of student borrowing of any state, topping out at $36,101 (with typical monthly payments of $366).

It shouldn’t be surprising that New Hampshire graduates borrow the most, since they face the highest in-state tuition costs in that nation, according to The College Board. At $15,650 a year, New Hampshire students pay three times more for their educations than those in the lowest-cost state, Wyoming.

These high student loans are a big burden on New Hampshire graduates, especially with the state’s living costs that are 14 percent higher than average.

2. New York

  • Average student loan balance: $29,320
  • Average annual wage: $57,030
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 25.83%

New York’s 2015 graduates actually had student loan debt below the national average, though higher than the median. A seemingly reasonable monthly payment of $297 turns out to be a financial burden for New Yorkers facing living costs that are 34.4 percent higher than the national average.

These high costs leave New York residents only $1,150 a month in disposable income, of which typical student loan payment would be more than a quarter. That’s despite New Yorkers earning some of the nation’s highest wages.

1. Hawaii (worst)

  • Average student loan balance: $23,456
  • Average annual wage: $47,740
  • Ratio of student payments to disposable income: 30.61%

At first glance, things seem pretty good for Hawaii college graduates. They have the sixth-lowest average student debt. And the state’s wages beat those in most other states, on par with the national average.

But the island state’s notoriously higher living costs are 43 percent above the national average. These extra costs stretch Hawaii residents’ budgets to the limits, leaving them $776 in disposable income each month — that’s less than half the study’s average of $1,663.

With disposable income so low, the average $237 monthly payment eats up over 30 percent of the typical graduate’s disposable income.

How can students lower the cost of student loans?

This survey shows that where borrowers attend college, live, and work can greatly affect whether they can afford their student loan payments. Some might have the deck stacked against even their best efforts to repay student loans thanks to lower wages and higher living costs.

But the Student Loan Hero study also reveals a few ways borrowers can improve their financial outlook post-graduation.

Rely less on borrowing to cover costs

Graduates with less debt can more easily afford student loan payments and build financial security. Sure, this might seem obvious, but it’s not uncommon for students to borrow more than they need simply because they don’t know their other options.

A University of Kansas study found that borrowers with an extra $10,000 in student loans accrue wealth much slower than their less-indebted peers, reports MarketWatch. Those with this extra debt will take 26 percent longer to reach the national median net worth.

In fact, our study found that at average wages and costs of living, a college graduate would need to limit total educational borrowing to $16,400 or less to keep repayment affordable. That’s the limit for student loan balances that can be covered with 10 percent or less of a typical graduate’s disposable income.

Compare income against cost of living

Our study also found that while earning higher income is a key component of a graduate’s ability to repay student loans, it has to be considered alongside local living costs.

This study’s rankings found that student loan affordability correlated more closely with a state’s living costs than with its median wages. That’s likely because cost of living varies more widely than salaries do. Additionally, states with higher living costs don’t always have higher wages to match.

In general, it might be more advantageous for graduates to consider jobs in states with lower cost of living and relatively higher wages.

Consider an income-driven repayment plan

As none of the states’ levels of student borrowing qualify as affordable, our study reveals how common it is for student borrowing to outpace graduates’ abilities to repay. Graduates who are having trouble keeping up with their student loans can see that, if nothing else, they’re not alone in this struggle.

Considering these findings, it’s likely that a significant portion of student loan borrowers in each state could qualify for lower payments under an income-driven repayment (IDR) plan. Graduates living in the worst states, in particular, are likely to benefit from enrolling in an income-driven plan. Lower payments under IDR can free up monthly cash flow and create some much-needed breathing room in borrowers’ budgets.

College students and graduates should do their part to limit borrowing and responsibly repay student loans. But overall, Student Loan Hero’s study findings prove that student debt is far past the point of affordability for typical college graduates — no matter where they live.

Methodology

This study compared average earning in each state* to costs of living and average student loan balances to find the states where student loan repayment is most affordable.

First, the disposable income of an average worker was calculated in each state. This was based on the Bureau of Labor Statistic’s reported mean wage in the state, less living expenses such as housing, transportation, food, and health care (based on national consumer data and adjusted for cost of living).

This disposable income was compared to typical payments on the average student debt balance of a 2014 graduate in each state. This was based on a 10-year repayment term, assuming a 4% interest rate.

In line with federal standards for student loan affordability, student loan monthly payments equal to 10 percent or less of monthly disposable income were considered affordable.

*Note: North Dakota was excluded from this study due to insufficient data on student loan borrowing in the state.

Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics, The Council for Community and Economic Research’s Cost of Living Index, The Institute for College Access & Success

Interested in refinancing student loans?

Here are the top 6 lenders of 2018!
LenderRates (APR)Eligible Degrees 
Check out the testimonials and our in-depth reviews!
2.75% - 7.24%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit SoFi
2.57% - 6.39%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit Earnest
2.57% - 7.12%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit CommonBond
2.99% - 6.99%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit Laurel Road
2.74% - 7.26%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit Lendkey
2.89% - 8.33%Undergrad
& Graduate
Visit Citizens
Advertiser Disclosure

Student Loan Hero Advertiser Disclosure

Our team at Student Loan Hero works hard to find and recommend products and services that we believe are of high quality and will make a positive impact in your life. We sometimes earn a sales commission or advertising fee when recommending various products and services to you. Similar to when you are being sold any product or service, be sure to read the fine print, understand what you are buying, and consult a licensed professional if you have any concerns. Student Loan Hero is not a lender or investment advisor. We are not involved in the loan approval or investment process, nor do we make credit or investment related decisions. The rates and terms listed on our website are estimates and are subject to change at any time. Please do your homework and let us know if you have any questions or concerns.