Is Lowering Your Student Loan Payments a Good Idea? Here’s How to Decide

lower-student-loan-payments

We get a lot of questions about how to lower student loan payments—and there are some legitimate reasons for wanting to do this. But in a variety of situations, it isn’t a good idea and can make repaying your loans more difficult and expensive.

The decision to lower student loan payments really depends on the reason behind it. So, why wouldn’t you want to lower monthly payments? The main reason is that you could end up paying more interest on your loans and increasing the amount of time until they’re paid off. But this isn’t always the case (more on this below).

Here’s when you might, or might not, want to consider reducing your monthly student loan payments.

Consider lowering student loan payments when…

1. Student loan payments eat up a large portion of your paycheck

Just as there are some people who can afford to pay more, others with student loan debts may have financial hardships that keep them from making standard payment amounts. Maybe you’re not earning enough to make your payments and still be able to pay for basic necessities. Or maybe you’ve lost your job or decided to go back to school.

If student loans are causing financial problems, lowering payments is likely the first step to getting things under control. And you can always increase payments later if you choose to.

While there’s no set amount or percentage of income that works for everyone, it’s good to think of payments in these terms. If you have a decent-paying job and can’t afford to pay at least 10 percent of your net income towards your student loans, you may want to reassess your spending before lowering payments.

Keep in mind: Paying more than 10 percent or paying the minimum is possible. Kristin paid off $12,000 in one year. Stephanie paid off about $35,000 in less than four years. Neither paid the minimum or tried to lower payments to pay off their loans.

2. You’re at risk for late payments or defaulting on your loan

To take the above example further, it’s likely to make even more sense to pay less on student loans when you’re at risk of missing payments or defaulting on your loans.

Missing student loan payments is never a good idea, especially if you’re able to change the repayment amount or schedule instead. Missing payments show up on your credit report and can kill your credit score. These late payments stay on your credit report for years.

Defaulting on your student loans is even worse. If you’ve missed many payments, you could end up in default and owe even more on your debt. In this case, you could see extra fees and charges tacked onto your student loan debt. These add to the cost, causing greater problems as you strive to repay your loans.

3. You’re likely to be eligible for forgiveness in the future

While every borrower will be eligible for the income-based Pay As You Earn plan later this year, only some might benefit from student loan forgiveness.

The Pay As You Earn plan caps your payments at 10 percent of your discretionary income. After 20 years of payments, you can have the remaining federal student loan balance forgiven. But the big question is: Will you have a balance left to be forgiven?

Let’s look at the example of what the U.S. Department of Education’s Repayment Estimator says is the average loan balance for the most expensive schooling options: a four-year private, for-profit university. In this case, you’d have an average balance of $34,722 with 3.9% interest.

Assuming a fairly low, starting adjusted gross income of $20,000, you’d have $38,877 forgiven after 20 years with Pay As You Earn. In total, you’d pay $22,928. This is about $19,000 less in total payments compared to the standard repayment ($41,988 total paid).

Lower_student_loan_payments_-_image_1

Source: Studentloans.gov

Besides the Pay As You Earn plan, there’s the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program. With this program, you can have select federal loans forgiven after 10 years of working at a qualified nonprofit or public sector job. In this case, you may be more likely to have debt forgiven since it’s 10 years instead of 20 until you’re eligible for forgiveness.

In any case, be sure to investigate your situation. Use student loan calculators, and do the math first before determining your eligibility to have loans forgiven.

4. When you can refinance to save money

Refinancing is one of the few instances where you can potentially lower student loan payments and save money. The reason? You’re typically lowering interest rates and reducing interest charges.

This is often the case when you refinance and consolidate to lower private student loan payments. However, this strategy can potentially work with some federal student loans too.

If you’re looking into reducing your payments, check out our student loan refinancing options, and see how your payments may change if you qualify.

Avoid lowering student loan payments when…

1. You can afford your current payments

While there are clearly some grads who need this kind of help, some don’t. But they may still be eligible for these reduced repayment options.

The real problem with these repayment plans, such as Income-Based Repayment? You’ll pay more interest and make more total payments as you repay your debt. It’s simple—any time you decrease payments without lowering the interest rate too, you’re going to accrue more interest.

This case should also be considered with the next one.

2. You likely won’t benefit from federal student loan forgiveness

I’ve seen many people get excited about student loan forgiveness. The idea is you make payments for 20 years, and after that your remaining student loan balances are forgiven. The problem is that, depending on how much debt you have, there might not be much left to forgive.

Let’s look at the previous scenario for forgiveness again ($34,722 balance with 3.9% interest).

This time, we’ll assume your adjusted gross income starts at $30,000 (rather than $20,000). Run the numbers in the Repayment Estimator again, and you’ll find you won’t have any debt left to be forgiven under Pay As You Earn.

Instead, you’ll have paid a total of $53,329 to repay your loans. This is about $12,000 more than if you had repaid your loans with the standard repayment plan ($41,988 total).

lower_student_loan_payments_-_image_2

Source: Studentloans.gov

In this case, attempting to get forgiveness is a money-losing decision.

3. You’re waiting for outside help from the government

You’ve probably heard about the possibility of the government helping you to refinance loans. Senator Elizabeth Warren’s proposal includes reducing all federal student loan interest rates to the current lowest rate.

While it sounds great, don’t hold your breath. Congress has shown little willingness to pass this or any other bill, so you’re limited to the current repayment options and interest rates for the foreseeable future.

What do you think? Should you lower your student loan payments or not?

Interested in refinancing student loans?

Here are the top 6 lenders of 2017!
LenderRates (APR)Eligible Degrees 
Check out the testimonials and our in-depth reviews!
2.34% - 6.74%Undergrad & GraduateVisit SoFi
3.64% - 7.20%Undergrad & GraduateVisit DRB
2.55% - 6.74%Undergrad & GraduateVisit Earnest
2.35% - 7.74%Undergrad & GraduateVisit CommonBond
2.22% - 7.26%Undergrad & GraduateVisit LendKey
2.38% - 8.24%Undergrad & GraduateVisit Citizens
Advertiser Disclosure

Student Loan Hero Advertiser Disclosure

Our team at Student Loan Hero works hard to find and recommend products and services that we believe are of high quality and will make a positive impact in your life. We sometimes earn a sales commission or advertising fee when recommending various products and services to you. Similar to when you are being sold any product or service, be sure to read the fine print, understand what you are buying, and consult a licensed professional if you have any concerns. Student Loan Hero is not a lender or investment advisor. We are not involved in the loan approval or investment process, nor do we make credit or investment related decisions. The rates and terms listed on our website are estimates and are subject to change at any time. Please do your homework and let us know if you have any questions or concerns.

Published in Credit, Federal Student Loan Repayment, Federal Student Loans, Income Based Repayment, Pay As You Earn (PAYE), Pay Off Student Loans, Private Student Loan Consolidation, Private Student Loan Refinancing, Public Service Loan Forgiveness, Student Loan Repayment

  • Hi Maria,

    That’s a good point. However, I’m not exactly sure what you mean by professionals have more options. The options seem more or less the same to me, but I suppose they way professionals use them could be different.

    In any case, is there something more specifically we could help with? Let us know.

    Best,

    Jeffrey
    Student Loan Hero

  • itasara

    After paying on his loan for two years my son still owes the same amount of money of his loan. He doesn’t make all that much. The loan never goes down. What does the government want of our educated children?? His rate is high 8%. He can’t change the rate. What a rip off!

  • Great tips. It’s important to seriously evaluate what will happen if you reduce your student loan payments — as most of the time you’re better off paying them off as quickly as possible. However, if you have some sort of loan forgiveness option (as a few of my friends working in healthcare do) it can certainly be smart to consider lowering your monthly payments. But, it’s still risky. What would happen if the loan forgiveness option became unavailable in 5 years? You’d be stuck paying off the original amount PLUS the additional interest.