Some consultants hired by colleges to reduce student loan default rates are giving advice to borrowers that increase their loan repayment costs or risk of default. That’s according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report out Thursday.
Many colleges hire consultants to counsel students struggling to repay their education loans. That’s because schools can lose access to federal financial aid if too many borrowers default during their first three years of repayment.
The GAO report found some consultants manipulate three-year default rates by pushing students into forbearance, which increases the long-term cost of loan repayment.
How student loan default consultants are failing borrowers
Colleges depend on students having access to federal financial aid to afford tuition. If too many borrowers default within the first three years of student loan repayment, the U.S. Department of Education can sanction the college and stop offering federal financial aid to its students.
To avoid triggering those sanctions, many colleges hire consultants to give advice to students in danger of default. The GAO took a close look at the advice given by nine default management consultants serving around 800 schools.
It found that four of the consultants provided inaccurate or incomplete information to borrowers; the other five routinely steered students toward forbearance when other approaches to repayment might have been more beneficial.
In many cases, consultants failed to explain repayment options to students that could prevent default, such as income-driven repayment plans. Some consultants also mailed forbearance applications to students who were past due on their debt, even though the students didn’t request the forms.
One consultant incorrectly told students a verbal request for forbearance could be processed within five minutes. Another wrongly told students that federal benefits such as food assistance could be lost due to default, and yet another offered gift cards to students who put loans into forbearance.
While forbearance can prevent default by putting payments on pause, it also increases total repayment costs; interest continues to accrue while certain loans are in forbearance.
Meanwhile, students who had their loans in long-term forbearance defaulted more often during their fourth year of repayment. While 1.7% of borrowers defaulted in the first three years of repayment during the time period the GAO reviewed, 9.4% defaulted in the fourth year.
Although it’s commonly used, forbearance isn’t a long-term solution for students. Sixty-eight percent of borrowers who entered repayment in 2013 placed loans into forbearance within three years, the GAO found. That group includes the 20% of borrowers who put loans into forbearance for at least 18 months.
As the chart below shows, pushing students into forbearance significantly reduces the risk of default during the first three years:
The GAO report suggests consultants are more concerned with reducing default rates for the school, rather than providing long-term solutions for students.
How are borrowers affected by poor advice?
When consultants provide incomplete advice or steer students toward forbearance, three things happen:
- Students face a bigger risk of default in the future.
- Students pay more in interest over the life of the loan.
- Default rates can’t be accurately measured.
The Department of Education imposes sanctions on schools with high default rates. With schools manipulating default rates, the government’s oversight is weakened. This means students could be blind to some low-performing educational institutions.
Further, borrowers might not be getting the guidance they need to avoid default. Forbearance could simply be delaying it. But a default can be devastating; it could destroy a borrower’s credit, lead to wage garnishment, and lead to a loss of federal benefits.
Borrowers who put loans into forbearance also unnecessarily pay more in interest over the life of their loans. The chart below shows additional costs of putting loans into forbearance.
What policy changes could be made to protect borrowers?
In the wake of the new report, some government officials are calling for policy changes to better protect students and hold schools accountable.
“The GAO’s report reveals an astonishing lack of accountability and transparency in the default management industry that results in borrowers owing thousands of dollars in additional debt and facing a greater risk of default,” Rep. Mark Takano, D-Calif., said in a press release. “The Department of Education must use the full extent of its authority to rein in abusive firms and protect student loan borrowers and taxpayers.”
The report recommended that the Department of Education change the way in which default rates are calculated to get more accurate measurements. Changes could include revising calculations to account for borrowers spending time in forbearance or adding additional accountability measures.
The GAO also urged Congress to require schools and debt management consultants to provide complete, accurate information about borrower options.
However, not all agree that the GAO report clearly indicates a need for change. James Manning, acting chief operating officer of the Department of Education, criticized the small number of consulting firms included in the GAO’s study, noting that just nine of 48 consulting firms were included, and only a small number of consultants and borrowers were interviewed.
Manning also objected to GAO’s criticisms that consulting firms only sent forbearance applications to borrowers without disclosing other options to students.
“While critical of a few consultants’ practice of sending forbearance applications to borrowers, GAO fails to acknowledge that the application itself provides an opportunity for borrowers to learn about other repayment options,” Manning said in a letter responding to the study.
How can students protect themselves?
Students need to be proactive in researching their options for student loan repayment; they cannot rely on just the advice of consultants or loan servicers.
Use trusted resources such as the Department of Education to learn about student loan repayment options. You could also check out our guide to avoiding student loan default. It’s your money at stake, so make sure you understand the long- and short-term implications of any repayment decision you make.
Interested in refinancing student loans?Here are the top 6 lenders of 2019!
|Lender||Variable APR||Eligible Degrees|
|Check out the testimonials and our in-depth reviews!
1 Important Disclosures for SoFi.
2 Important Disclosures for Earnest.
To qualify, you must be a U.S. citizen or possess a 10-year (non-conditional) Permanent Resident Card, reside in a state Earnest lends in, and satisfy our minimum eligibility criteria. You may find more information on loan eligibility here: https://www.earnest.com/eligibility. Not all applicants will be approved for a loan, and not all applicants will qualify for the lowest rate. Approval and interest rate depend on the review of a complete application.
Earnest fixed rate loan rates range from 3.89% APR (with Auto Pay) to 7.89% APR (with Auto Pay). Variable rate loan rates range from 2.54% APR (with Auto Pay) to 7.27% APR (with Auto Pay). For variable rate loans, although the interest rate will vary after you are approved, the interest rate will never exceed 8.95% for loan terms 10 years or less. For loan terms of 10 years to 15 years, the interest rate will never exceed 9.95%. For loan terms over 15 years, the interest rate will never exceed 11.95% (the maximum rates for these loans). Earnest variable interest rate loans are based on a publicly available index, the one month London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR). Your rate will be calculated each month by adding a margin between 1.82% and 5.50% to the one month LIBOR. The rate will not increase more than once per month. Earnest rate ranges are current as of March 18, 2019, and are subject to change based on market conditions and borrower eligibility.
Auto Pay discount: If you make monthly principal and interest payments by an automatic, monthly deduction from a savings or checking account, your rate will be reduced by one quarter of one percent (0.25%) for so long as you continue to make automatic, electronic monthly payments. This benefit is suspended during periods of deferment and forbearance.
The information provided on this page is updated as of 0318/2019. Earnest reserves the right to change, pause, or terminate product offerings at any time without notice. Earnest loans are originated by Earnest Operations LLC. California Finance Lender License 6054788. NMLS # 1204917. Earnest Operations LLC is located at 302 2nd Street, Suite 401N, San Francisco, CA 94107. Terms and Conditions apply. Visit https://www.earnest.com/terms-of-service, email us at email@example.com, or call 888-601-2801 for more information on ourstudent loan refinance product.
© 2018 Earnest LLC. All rights reserved. Earnest LLC and its subsidiaries, including Earnest Operations LLC, are not sponsored by or agencies of the United States of America.
3 Important Disclosures for Laurel Road.
Laurel Road Disclosures
However, if the borrower chooses to make monthly payments automatically by electronic funds transfer (EFT) from a bank account, the fixed rate will decrease by 0.25%, and will increase back up to the regular fixed interest rate described in the preceding paragraph if the borrower stops making (or we stop accepting) monthly payments automatically by EFT from the designated borrower’s bank account.
However, if the borrower chooses to make monthly payments automatically by electronic funds transfer (EFT) from a bank account, the variable rate will decrease by 0.25%, and will increase back up to the regular variable interest rate described in the preceding paragraph if the borrower stops making (or we stop accepting) monthly payments automatically by EFT from the designated borrower’s bank account.
4 Important Disclosures for LendKey.
Refinancing via LendKey.com is only available for applicants with qualified private education loans from an eligible institution. Loans that were used for exam preparation classes, including, but not limited to, loans for LSAT, MCAT, GMAT, and GRE preparation, are not eligible for refinancing with a lender via LendKey.com. If you currently have any of these exam preparation loans, you should not include them in an application to refinance your student loans on this website. Applicants must be either U.S. citizens or Permanent Residents in an eligible state to qualify for a loan. Certain membership requirements (including the opening of a share account and any applicable association fees in connection with membership) may apply in the event that an applicant wishes to accept a loan offer from a credit union lender. Lenders participating on LendKey.com reserve the right to modify or discontinue the products, terms, and benefits offered on this website at any time without notice. LendKey Technologies, Inc. is not affiliated with, nor does it endorse, any educational institution.
5 Important Disclosures for CommonBond.
Offered terms are subject to change. Loans are offered by CommonBond Lending, LLC (NMLS # 1175900). If you are approved for a loan, the interest rate offered will depend on your credit profile, your application, the loan term selected and will be within the ranges of rates shown.
All Annual Percentage Rates (APRs) displayed assume borrowers enroll in auto pay and account for the 0.25% reduction in interest rate. All variable rates are based on a 1-month LIBOR assumption of 2.5% effective February 10, 2019.
6 Important Disclosures for Citizens Bank.
Citizens Bank Disclosures
|2.54% – 7.12%3||Undergrad & Graduate|
|2.54% – 7.27%1||Undergrad & Graduate|
|2.67% – 8.96%4||Undergrad & Graduate|
|3.23% – 6.65%2||Undergrad & Graduate|
|2.69% – 7.43%5||Undergrad & Graduate|
|2.98% – 9.72%6||Undergrad & Graduate|